💰 $150K+ Revenue on This $750K Poconos STR
🏊 $750K for a ~20%+ gross rental yield, with a year-round indoor pool, 5 private acres + commercial zoning.
Alex Veytsman
September 07, 2026
🏊 $150K+ Revenue on a $750K Poconos STR — With an Indoor Pool + 5 Acres
💰 East Stroudsburg, PA • $750K • $150K+ Annual Rental Income • ~20%+ Gross Rental Yield • 4BR / 2.5BA • Indoor Heated Pool • 5 Acres • Commercial Zoning
📩 Interested?
🏊 $150K+ Revenue + a Year-Round Indoor Pool
This is the kind of STR where one major amenity can change the entire investment case.
Located in East Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, this turnkey property reportedly generates $150,000+ in annual rental income on a $750,000 asking price.
That's approximately a:
20%+ Gross Revenue-to-Price Ratio
The centerpiece is a separate year-round heated indoor pool with a 120-inch projector screen—an amenity that can help drive bookings even when the weather isn't cooperating.
Add 5 private acres, commercial zoning and a separate guest suite, and there's also potential flexibility beyond the STR that's operating today.
🏡 The Asset
5951 Milford Rd, East Stroudsburg, PA 18302
💰 Price: $750,000
💵 Annual Rental Income: $150K+
📊 Gross Revenue / Price: ~20%+
🛏️ 4 Bedrooms
🚿 2.5 Bathrooms
📐 2,840 Sq Ft
🌲 5 Private Acres
🏊 Separate Heated Indoor Pool
🎬 120" Poolside Projector Screen
🎱 Game Room With Pool Table + Darts
🏠 Private Suite With Separate Entrance, Kitchen + Bath
🔥 Fire Pit + Outdoor Gathering Areas
🏢 Commercial Zoning
💰 The Investment Case
At $150K+ in reported annual rental income, the $750K asking price represents roughly a 20%+ gross revenue-to-price ratio, or about 5x annual gross revenue.
That's gross revenue—not cap rate—but it's a compelling starting point for a property with documented rental performance.
The biggest differentiator is the indoor heated pool. Unlike a seasonal outdoor pool, it can be marketed year-round—and pairing it with a huge projector screen creates the kind of memorable amenity that can help an STR stand out.
The property also has a separate private suite with its own entrance, bedroom, bathroom and kitchen, creating additional flexibility for groups or different rental configurations.
🌲 5 Acres + Commercial Zoning = Optionality
The property sits on 5 private acres, with a hillside setting, fire pit, tent setup and room to potentially expand.
Even more interesting is the commercial zoning, which the listing says could provide flexibility to continue the STR operation, expand, or explore alternative commercial uses.
Any expansion or alternative use would, of course, be subject to applicable zoning, permitting and approvals.
And for STR demand, you're minutes from major Poconos attractions including Shawnee Mountain, Bushkill Falls and zip-lining.
📊 The Investment Story
💰 $750K Purchase Price
💵 $150K+ Annual Rental Income
📊 ~20%+ Gross Revenue / Price
🏊 Year-Round Heated Indoor Pool
🌲 5 Private Acres
🏢 Commercial Zoning
🏠 Separate Private Suite
🎱 Game Room
The thesis: buy a proven $150K+ revenue STR at roughly 5x gross revenue, with an indoor pool that can drive bookings year-round and 5 commercially zoned acres creating additional long-term optionality.
💸 Financing + Cost Segregation
A property with $150K+ in documented rental income may be worth evaluating with lenders that understand vacation-rental properties and STR income.
Depending on the borrower, property and lender requirements, potential structures can include DSCR, conventional investment, portfolio and other STR-focused financing options.
🧾 Cost Segregation
Qualifying investors may also want to evaluate whether cost segregation and bonus depreciation could make sense after acquisition.
We partner with Segonomics, the lowest-priced cost segregation partner we've found.
Offer Sheet readers get 20% off using code:
OS20OFF
Members of Offer Sheet Pro can receive:
50% OFF
with studies as low as $1,749.
Offer Sheet Pro members can reply to the newsletter for the private 50% discount code.
Cost segregation, bonus depreciation and the ability to use resulting deductions depend on the property and each investor's individual tax situation. Consult a qualified tax professional.
🏡 Want Help Buying the Right STR?
Finding a property is only one part of building a successful short-term rental.
We partner with a team that helps investors with the entire process—from choosing the right market and finding the property to underwriting, design, amenities and operations.
They can help with:
📍 Market Selection — identify markets that fit your budget, goals and investment strategy.
🔎 Property Search — find STR opportunities without spending hours every day combing through listings.
📊 Deal Underwriting — analyze individual properties and revenue potential before you commit.
🎨 Design + Furnishing — create an STR designed to stand out from competing rentals.
🔥 Revenue-Driving Amenities — determine which upgrades can meaningfully improve bookings and the guest experience.
⚙️ Launch + Operations — help put the pieces in place to get the property live and operating successfully.
In order to work with them, they typically require having around $150,000 available for your down payment, furnishing, design, and revenue-driving amenities so you're positioned for success from day one.
To date, they've helped investors acquire 375+ properties, generating $60M+ in rental revenue with $25M+ in estimated tax savings.
Whether you need help figuring out where to buy, which property to choose, what it could generate, or how to design and amenity it to compete at the top of its market, they can help throughout the process.
💰 Thinking About Selling Your STR?
Already own a short-term rental and thinking about selling?
The Offer Sheet can put your property directly in front of an audience of active STR investors who are specifically looking for vacation rentals, including properties with proven revenue histories.
Whether your property is listed publicly or you want to explore an off-market sale, we can help get it in front of potential buyers.
Have a strong-performing Airbnb, unique vacation rental, or turnkey STR you may consider selling? Send it our way.
🎯 Why This One Stands Out
💰 $150K+ Rental Income
At $750K, that's a compelling ~20%+ gross revenue-to-price ratio.
🏊 Year-Round Indoor Pool
A rare, weather-proof amenity that can differentiate the property across every season.
🌲 5 Private Acres
Privacy today with potential room for future expansion.
🏢 Commercial Zoning
Adds another layer of potential flexibility and long-term optionality.
🏠 Separate Private Suite
Its own entrance, kitchen and bathroom create additional rental flexibility.
⚡ Bottom Line
$750K. $150K+ Revenue. Indoor Pool. 5 Acres. Commercial Zoning.
At roughly 5x reported annual gross revenue, this one combines strong existing STR performance with one of the better year-round amenities you can have in the Poconos: a private heated indoor pool.
Add the acreage, separate suite and commercial zoning, and there's potentially more upside here than simply continuing to operate the property exactly as it sits today.
📩 Interested in This Property?
